books with Athena

books with Athena

Sunday, July 4, 2010


This is an update of a list I ran a year ago, when I first started this blog. It was blessed with a recommendation from the editor who blogs as Moonrat and a visit (and added tip) from agent Janet Reid, the QueryShark herownself.

I figure it’s worth posting again—with Ms. Reid’s addendum—since a fresh flock of newbies will have hatched from their writing hidey-holes in the last 12 months—and the predators are still out there, waiting to pounce. Just look at all those ads flashing on your gmail page every time you use the word “publish” in an email to your Mom. (Is it just me or is that Big-Brother creepy?)

Scammers prey on the clueless—especially people who think spending cash up front will "pay off" because their book is a surefire path to fame and fortune—and the ones who believe their superior talent gives them a “Get Out of Slushpilehell Free” card.

The sad truth is that finding literary representation is a long, miserable slog. Most writers query for years—even decades—receiving nothing but rejection after heartbreaking rejection. It's not just about writing well or querying well. It's about hitting the right agent on the right day at the right point in the current trend's curve. The writers who make it have to be in for the long haul.

Don’t blame the real agents. They’re reading their little eyeballs out. But the Association of Author’s Representatives has less than 500 members, while most of the 230 million of us who own computers have at least one novel in progress in the files.

Agent Greg Daniel of Daniel Literary Group tweeted last week “Stats show 80% of Americns want to write a bk, yet only 57% have read at least 1 bk in the last yr. And that's why there's a slushpilehell”

If as many Americans read books as wrote them, we might not be in this fix, so: if you really want to improve your chances of finding an agent, go buy a book. Buy ten. Especially new writers in your genre. (Befriend them. When you do get your book deal, maybe they’ll give you a blurb or a plug on their blog.)

Here are seven pointers to help you hang onto your dwindling cash reserves during this soul-crushing process:

You know this, but do pass it on to the fledglings. Any agent who charges money to read your manuscript isn’t going to help your career. Publishers consider it unethical and won’t do business with them.

If you have to pay somebody to read your book, it’s not ready for publication. When you need professional advice, DO pay a qualified freelance editor or book doctor, but never with a promise of publication attached. They can’t deliver.

A popular scam. Bogus agencies sign thousands of clients and charge them each $250 or more per quarter for “copying and mailing.” But they never make a sale. I’ve seen heartbreaking letters from writers who’ve lost as much as $3,000 before they caught on.

Small agencies may legitimately ask for copying and mailing fees AFTER they’ve sent out your work, but they’ll provide proof they’re sending out your manuscript.

A librarian friend once forwarded me an intriguing ad from a prestigious journal--for a literary agency asking for submissions. I visited the agency's refreshingly positive website and almost fell into the trap until I Googled them.They appeared on the list of “20 WORST AGENTS” at the Writer Beware site.

Do the math: real agents don’t have to advertise.

If there’s no client page on their website, run. Agents don’t keep client lists “confidential.” If they represent a literary star, they’ll pound their chests and bellow about it.

Even if somebody in the agency can claim to have represented Steven King, if it happened in King’s pre-Carrie days and she hasn’t sold a book since, she won’t be able to sell yours.

A good agent will always send on your rejections, usually every quarter. Some scammers do send manuscripts to publishing houses, but only in mass mailings addressed to no particular editor. Those go into recycling without a response.


AgentQuery is the easiest site to search for basic agent info I suggest any beginner start here. Their forums are useful too.

I also recommend joining QueryTracker. It’s free and has detailed agent info as well as recent feedback from fellow queriers.

And before you contact any agent, make sure you check with those tireless watchdogs at Writer Beware,

…and Preditors and Editors,

…and Absolute Write.

You may have been told to check with the Association of Authors Representatives, but it’s important to note that an agent does NOT have to be a member of AAR to be legitimate and even top-notch. New agents have to work for a certain number of years before they’re allowed to join—and it’s the newer and hungrier agents who are interested in new writers and actively building their lists.

And about those peckish non-AAR agents: Here’s Janet Reid’s useful bit of advice:

From Ms. Reid: “Young and hungry agents who are looking for clients may indeed not be members of AAR, but what you can ask them (BEFORE SIGNING!) is what literary agency they have worked in. Interned in or worked in. I'm always rather taken aback by people who decide they can be literary agents without actually having been inside an agent's office.”

And remember Google is your friend. Always check ’em out.


  1. Great info. You save us all so much leg work! The last agent I got close to signing with sent me an elaborate package "selling" himself to me. me suspicious. Then, when I talked to him, he suggested I pay him to write the screenplay version of my novel. Said it would make a great movie. Yeah, right. Thanks but no thanks!

  2. I agree that we writers must support the market in which we want to participate as authors. To your list of links, I would add Publishers Marketplace which for $20 a month offers the most complete listing of up-to-date agent and publisher deals, in addition to a great deal of other useful information. The subscription is per month and can be cancelled or renewed at any time. The URL is:

  3. I fell for a bad agent once. It left me feeling lower than low. But I got up, dusted off and started over; this time with the proper resources to make a good decision. I wrote about it on my blog, and admitting that it happened really helped me move on.

  4. Thanks - great advice. All writers should read this!

  5. Andrea and Christine, thanks for sharing your scam experiences. It can happen to anybody when they're just starting out. Wow. The screenplay angle is an especially creative one, isn't it?

    Judith, Publisher's Marketplace is the gold standard, of course, but I want to let people know all the info they need to protect themselves is available for free.

    Simon and Yvonne, spread the word!

  6. Blogger had a hissy fit last night and erased any comments that were made yesterday. So if you commented and your comment is gone--it wasn't me. Thanks for trying.

    So again: many thanks to Christine and Andrea for sharing their agent scam experiences. The screenplay angle is pretty creative, isn't it?

    Judith--Publisher's Marketplace is absolutely the gold standard, but I want people to know the information they need to protect themselves is available at no cost.

    Simon and Yvonne. Thanks! And spread the word.

  7. Hi Anne! Yeah, that bad old Blogger was giving ME a hissy fit last night! Thanks for all this info and wanted to let you know that yes, your comment on my blog, did post!! Thanks!!

  8. Blogger just eliminated most of my comments! This is WTF time! I can't believe it. Now I'm down to four comments. I had at least eight a little bit ago.

    This happening to anybody else?

  9. Yes! Somebody posted a comment on my blog. I read it. Next day it was gone. He posted a WTF comment. Had to say, I dunno. Well, let's see if Blogger has settled down and see if this comment sticks.

  10. Churadogs, your comment stuck, but one is still missing. The original post supposedly has 10 comments, but when I click on the 10, only 9 comments come up. So I guess that agent's comment is gone forever. I'll have to live with the mystery.

  11. good points and a great reminder!

  12. Miss Snark is the ultimate flim flam scam agent who has never sold a book to an advance and royalty paying publisher. Emily Hanlon

  13. Emily, you're misinformed. "Miss Snark" is the pseudonym of a very successful and high profile agent who reps a large stable of bestselling authors. For legal reasons, she prefers to leave the Snarkives anonymous.


We LOVE comments, but we can't allow anonymous ones because of spam problems (like hundreds a day). We moderate comments on posts older than one week, since older posts attract more spam. Make sure you're signed into WordPress or Google before you type your comment or it may disappear. (No, I don't control this stuff.) If you still have trouble commenting, email your comment to me at annerallen dot allen at gmail dot com and I will post it for you.