Zombies are HOT in the publishing world. I know this because pretty much every issue of Publisher’s Lunch for the past year has reported stupendous deals for writers of zombie fiction. This includes one headlined seven-book deal—planning for years of zombiemania to come.
So lock your doors and windows, fellow reader-persons. We are in the midst of an invasion of literary zombies, nonfiction zombies, romantic zombies, high school zombies, historical zombies, and anthologized zombies. All eating brains at a bookstore near you.
And to make way for all this zombification, our corporate masters (aka the Big Six publishing companies) aren’t buying much other adult fiction. At least I guess that’s why agents report editors aren’t buying the following genres: romantic comedies, family sagas, action-adventure, high fantasy, sci-fi, westerns, historicals, literary fiction, most mysteries, thrillers by anybody other than James Patterson or Dan Brown—and pretty much anything that does NOT involve women falling in love with angsty immortal beings.
And zombies.
Maybe it’s just me, but I don’t see how brain-eating, festering undead persons have such a universal appeal. Most book-buyers are women over forty. Zombies aren’t really our thing. Don’t get me wrong, I was as big a fan of George Romero’s classic Living Dead films as any college kid ingesting controlled substances, but I’M A GROWN-UP NOW
So I’m talking to you, fellow grown-ups. OK, Zombieland was a hoot, and you bought Pride and Prejudice and Zombies for the hilarious cover—although you probably never got around to opening it—but are you plunking down your hard-earned, Recession-era cash money for the latest Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Zombies, or whatever—and all six sequels?
Our corporate masters say you will. You will all stampede down to your local B&N and demand these books like a mindless horde of, um, zombies.
This is supposed to happen because of the self-fulfilling prophesy that is the religion of marketing strategists: severely limit people’s choices through distribution control, rationed advertising, and kick-backs—then declare “the people have chosen” your product.
You can see this phenomenon at work any time you shop for a utilitarian plastic object at your local mall. Maybe few years ago you decorated your kitchen in the Wedgwood blue that was everywhere, but now you can’t find a dishpan in any color but used-chewing-gum beige or coagulated-blood red. You go to Kmart, Walmart, Big Boxmart or wherever, and find the identical dishpan in the same two colors in every store. Acres of them—all the same. So you’re finally bullied into buying a used-chewing-gum beige dishpan…and THE MARKET HAS SPOKEN! Everybody LOVES used-chewing-gum beige.
And zombies.
I haven’t forgotten them. But, you know, when I look at the bestseller list, I don’t see a lot of zombitude. I see the top bestsellers for many months have been three mysteries by a dead Scandinavian, who probably couldn’t get published in his lifetime because “nothing was selling” but zombies, or vampires, or chick lit, or the faux-fad of that particular year.
I know all this is depressing as hell, but I do have something hopeful to say. This is it: I think the e-book revolution is about to eat the brains of that whole resistance-is-futile, one-size-fits-all paradigm.
When readers can buy $2.99 books, wherever, whenever the whim strikes, book sales can’t be controlled by simply paying chain stores to put certain titles in the front of the store and buying a full-page ad in the NYT Book Review.
Niche sites will start to review and market niche books. Readers will have more choices. Because it’s less risky to buy a $2.99 e-book than a $25 hardback, buyers can take chances on something new without needing to hear “it’s what’s selling” from their inner sheep.
Whether or not you decide to buy an e-reader (I’m personally not ready to take the plunge) they’re good news for writers. Especially if e-stores continue to pay high royalties for lower-priced books.
Most of us will probably still need agents and publishers, but they’ll serve slightly different functions. The market will fragment, but that’s not a bad thing. We may end up with a system like broadcast/cable TV where instead of a whole nation watching The Ed Sullivan Show on a Sunday night, some can see Mad Men while others enjoy watching tear-jerking home remodels or really rude people from New Jersey .
What’s happening is Chris Anderson’s “long-tail” theory at work. Long tail theory says niches, when considered collectively, represent a substantial market that shouldn't be ignored.
So don’t join the zombie march. By the time you hit chapter seven, zombie lit will probably have gone the way of chick lit—made toxic by frenzied over-buying. Keep writing in your favorite genre, hone your craft, join niche organizations and wait. I predict the e-reader will have a very long tail—which will be great for writers.
But maybe not for zombies.
18 comments:
Without regeneration, I don't think I'll be latching onto any Zombie fiction. What would the happily ever after-ish ending look like?
Good point, Elaine. Zombie love would always come to an icky, smelly end. Downer endings aren't so good for sales.
Drat!
There goes my seven-book romance-eco-thriller in which zombies mutate, no longer eating human brains, but thriving instead on saltwater-laced crude oil. Imagine the thrill, the heartbreak, the environmental triumph, the really sloppy kisses, as our ever-increasing tribe of hero zombies cleans up oil spills all over the world! One more idea out the proverbial window.
Thanks, Anne, for another great post.
Charlie
I don't get the zombie thing, or the vampire thing, I never have.
I do however write something eerily similar to 'chick lit' though really not because it's more like old movie than HBO series.
In fact, I remember finding your blog because of a comment you made on another blog asking (and the question was never answered if I remember right) if there was a time coming where intelligent romances would have a shot.
Geez, I hope so. Even if mine have to go straight to e-reader which honestly sounds a lot more appealing all damn day long...
thanks for the great post!
bru
CHESTER/CHARLIE,
A SLUDGE-EATING ZOMBIE COOKBOOK IS JUST THE THING THIS WORLD NEEDS. GOFERIT! JUST KEEP PIGS OUT OF THE STEW.
---RRRANDY WURST
AND AS FOR ANNE'S OVER-ARCHING MOAN ABOUT PRINT PUBLISHING DECISION-MAKERS, I'M THINKING THEY ARE BLOODLESS (FROM VAMPIRIANA) AND BRAINLESS (FROM ZOMBIANA), AND PROBABLY NO ONE'S OUT OF THEIR 20S BECAUSE THE OLD FARTS AT THE TOP OF THE CORPORATE CHAIN PROBABLY GOT THEIR RECORDS STUCK ON THE BOB DYLAN(?) DICTUM OF NOT TRUSTING ANYONE OVER 30. OR WAS THAT ANDY WARHOL? DOES THAT MAKE ANY SENSE? NO? GOOD, LET'S PUBLISH IT.
Lovely post as usual Anne. I'm so sick of the market being over run by the dead and undead. When are these publishers going to put some mainstream fiction back into the mix. I want something fun damn it, instead of bloody and smelly and dangerous.
And I know they're also now taking books that have the apocolyptic theme in them for the whole undiverse is going to implode because the Mayans (or was it Incans) calendar said so in 2012, so we get to look forward to all that doom and gloom.
I think the zombie thing is partly a response to political correctness. You can't vilify whole groups anymore, but if they're the undead, by golly, it's all right to kill 'em. I think video games have added to this, since there's such a backlash against realistic violence for young people. Who's it OK to blast into oblivion? Aliens and the undead. You can't have explosions and violence and superhuman heroism involving cool weaponry without a target. Maybe we should found a zombie preservation movement. That'll clear this trend out.
I suspect the same forces at work on films is at work in Zombieland traditional publishing. It takes a huge effort, lots of up-front money, time, committment to make a film and/or print/distribute/promote a book, so the money boys are very, very cautious and will do the circus elephant trunk-to-tail follow along once the first elephant gets applause. Alas, the interest soon fades but you're still stuck with all these elephants in the pipeline which quickly end up on the remaindered table or go straight to video.
The e-publishing route costs relatively zip, can hit quickly like a rave, then disappear, then it's onto the next Big Thing. No giant investment to be guarded, no two-year lead time & etc.
Guerrilla publishing, hit and run all the way to the bank. Ka-CHING! Zombies one day, tigers the next.
And, nice thing, niches can be pretty huge, when you think about them. The trick is to get found and right now Amazon's Creepy Algothrim Machine keeps trying to introduce me to his sister, pssst. The more than improves, the better the chance people will have using some kind of search machine, like plug in "Swedish Zombie Tatoo Women," then wait to see how many titles pop up.
Oooooh I have such smart followers. Lots of great comments here.
Chura, yes indeed. With the coming plethora of ebooks, will need exactly such a search engine and we will have to carefully title our books by key words (maybe we already should.)Love the elephant metaphor. You've got it exactly right.
I'm with Randy, Chester--the world does need that Zombiefood petroleum-based cookbook.
KLM, you make a fascinating point. It makes perfect sense. These days you aren't allowed to put down anybody,(except fat people, who are no fun because they don't fight back) so you have to bring on the aliens and zombies. Time for the zombie community to organize!
PW and Bru, I'm soooo with you, as you know. What I want most in the world is for somebody to bring back the sophisticated romantic comedy. The kind with Cary Grant and Katherine Hepburn sipping martinis and exchanging bon mots while ignoring the dead body or panther in the pantry. Not Ben Stiller farting. Not Bridget Jones falling on her butt. Maybe we should start our own e-book line?
Anne,
Great points; I do agree. I like a good zombie work but the current vogue discourages me from joining in : it's too obvious, it's too boring and, yes, by the time you've finished you'll probably have missed the boat anyway ...
I'm so annoyed with zombies. I have no interest in them (nor will I ever). I guess I'll just have to keep re-reading my bookshelves... and I thought I was sick to death of vampires....
Great points Anne. I personally don't see the attraction to multiple zombie books, but the point you make at the end...that they'll go the way of chick lit is intersting. I don't think it's that chick lit and zombie lit is over saturated (although that is certainly true).I Think that chick lit and zombie lit are limited by certain factors. For traditional style chick lit-- the stories of shoes and sex and cities-- that's been done and it's old and there are only so many stories one can read about that topic. For zombie lit, same thing, although rather minus the shoes and the sex.
What I'm saying is that those tropes are limited in a way, and I think that's what really kills them. Same with Amish lit. Those stories can't be too different or else they break the convention.
Great post.
I'm sorry but was this post about Zombies? I couldn't tell. I think Zombies should have been the main topic of this post if it wasn't. Ha ha!
I loved this post, and since it's my first time visiting I can safely say I'll be back for more! I love meeting a fellow writer, especially one who is published and written romance, since I'm a sucker for romance!
I can handle a few zombie books but this overload, invasion style will have me on an overdose and once I've read too many the zombie world will fall fast... and hard.
Wow. This post should be in print Anne. Like in the New Yorker or someplace that has loads of readers. Great opinion piece. Entertaining and thought provoking.
I do like the odd zombie or vampire story. But I also like variety.
Love your thoughts on the e-book topic.
Definitely not a zombie person myself. I bought P&P&zombies and I read first few pages and then put it down. *shakes head*
Anne, I would love to read what you would come up with in this genre- you and PW too, you know it!!! There have to be readers for books like that! We want them, someone else must too!
bru
Thanks Bru! Sierra writes in our genre, too. We could start our own publishing company to bring back the sophisticated romantic comedy. Something like "Kate Books" named for Katherine Hepburn. Something to think about. If it weren't so much work...
Post a Comment